Articles by Paaras Panndya — Fractional CMO & Growth Strategist
Insights on Growth, Marketing Systems & Revenue Strategy
Actionable frameworks, real-world case studies, and strategic thinking for founders and marketing leaders building predictable growth.
Why Marketing Decisions Fail When Businesses Misunderstand How Customers Buy
Customer Buying Behaviour: Why Marketing Decisions Fail When Businesses Misunderstand How Customers Buy

Introduction:

Your Marketing Strategy May Not Be the Problem

A total of 20,000 visitors viewed each page on average each week. Less than 1% of those visitors took any action.

The teams answer: “We need a redesign.” In the past 17 years I’ve heard this statement in the boardroom, and it has almost always been wrong. A better question to ask yourself would be; “How do your customers make decisions?” Most companies have not taken the time to find out.

What Is Customer Buying Behaviour and Why Does It Matter?

How customers decide to buy can be viewed as the path they travel from “Do I really need this?” to “Yes, I will purchase.” The rational thinking can be the price, features and reviews of the product. The emotional thinking can be trust, fear of remorse, what others think of the product. There are many steps in the decision-making process of buying that are done behind the scenes. For example sending a text message on WhatsApp to a friend to ask if a certain brand is good.

The effectiveness of any contact that you make as a marketer, such as setting a price, or creating a title for a piece of content, is based on a reasonable assumption about the path that the customer is on. If your assumption turns out to be incorrect, then the money spent will have been lost; even if the quality of the creative work is excellent.

The Customer Buying Journey: What Happens Before a Purchase?

Nobody buys at first glance. Most people will look around your site, leave, search for you online, forget about your company, then return one week later.

  • Early stage: they feel the problem but don’t know your name
  • Middle stage: five tabs open, comparing

Then, after that, when there is an unanswered question, the tab will close. Harvard Business Review had an article about “jobs to be done.” It states that customers use products to progress in life, not to own features. Each step should have its own message. “Buy Now” can work for a customer who is ready to buy, but it will only irritate a customer who has only recently discovered your company. 

5 Pain Points of Customers That Companies Frequently Ignore

Here is an example of this from my work. A large printing and design company with around 20,000 visitors per week to a partnership page on their site was experiencing a conversion rate on that page of less than 1% as opposed to their goal of 3%. Everyone in the company believed that the problem was with the design of the page. After reviewing the page, I found 5 other problems with the page as well.

Pain point What the buyer saw 
Unanswered objection Nothing answering “why not go to the partner directly?” 
Wrong visual A dense product dashboard, shown to a first-time business owner 
No proof Zero testimonials on a page asking for commitment 
Competing buttons Several calls to action, no clear next step 
Fuzzy pricing A freemium plan that never said when free turns paid 

What the marketing decisions go wrong when brands overlook buyer behaviour

What happens when brands don’t consider buyer behaviour?

The call for redesign was not scientific but based on personal opinion. The web page received good traffic and the page itself looked very professional. The page didn’t, however, make a convincing case, it didn’t offer a clear rationale for choosing this option over the obvious one.

This is a typical error in making marketing decisions. Usually, a senior executive just states a preference without assessing it based on actual customer buying behavior. There are two common practices that are strongly contributing to such results.

  • Fixing how things look before reading how buyers think
  • Paying for more traffic to a page that can’t convert what it already gets

The numbers are in the full case study.

How Consumer Behaviour and Marketing Research Improve Decisions

We started with a diagnostic, not a design brief. The page scored 72 out of 140, and clarity above the fold scored just 61. Then we made three moves:

  • Put the whole argument in the first fold and swapped the dashboard for a relatable business-owner scene
  • Added a small pricing table, plus testimonials placed where people were stalling

Conversion was below one percent (1%) when we started, but now it is up to twelve percent (12%), which is four times our goal. Our diagnostic score has reached 114. Traffic has remained steady at 20,000 visitors per week, and we did not increase our advertising budget.

That is what you get when you study the buying habits of your customers and conduct marketing research. You do not need to spend thousands of dollars to do this. Simply contact five people who purchased from you in the last few months and find out why they almost did not.

Building a Brand Positioning Strategy Around What Customers Value

The talk Simon Sinek gave called “Start With Why” is an excellent 18-minute presentation of this idea. Your position is simply your explanation for why people should choose you instead of the next most likely alternative. That site did not provide an answer to this question, which caused users to leave the site.

A successful brand positioning strategy is based on the feedback of what customers love and dislike. Tell customers what you do well, tell them what you could do better, back up these claims with concrete examples, and then use that same message in all of your marketing efforts (website, sales pitch, advertising).

How Marketing Strategy Consulting Helps Businesses Understand Buyers

Marketing Strategy Consulting will be more beneficial for you if it is based upon your buyers rather than your channels. That 90-day sprint was performed under my role as a Fractional CMO. It was started with a diagnostic process rather than a redesign. You should be cautious of anyone who makes recommendations about channels prior to finding out who your customers are and why they are hesitating.

Conclusion: Understand the Buyer Before You Sell

Customer buying behaviour sits under every campaign you run. Before you buy more traffic, find out what your current visitors couldn’t understand. That gap is usually cheaper to close than to outspend.

Want a second pair of eyes on your funnel? Book a 30-minute growth conversation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should startups invest in branding before ads?

The advertising is what brings customers in, however, if your message isn’t clear and there’s no evidence of why they should buy from you then you’ll lose those potential customers as quickly as you got them. It starts with a simple, clear positioning statement and some real-life testimonials.

How long does brand building take to show results?

A customer is likely to return and engage more deeply with you after approximately 3-6 months. However, it will take about 1-2 years before they truly recognize your business.

Can ads build a brand?

Consistent messaging works. Sales from discount-only advertising are high, but brand loyalty is low.

How do I find out why customers don’t buy?

Ask them. Calls with lost leads and exit surveys beat dashboards.

Is a low conversion rate always a traffic problem?

In this instance, the traffic did not change at all. The page just couldn’t respond to an objection.

Table of Contents

AUTHOR

Paaras Panndya
Fractional CMO & Growth Strategist

Paaras Panndya works with startups and growth-stage companies to design scalable marketing systems that drive predictable revenue. With over a decade of experience in strategic marketing leadership, he helps businesses align strategy, technology, and teams for sustainable growth.

Related Articles

Positioning debt is what piles up when a company never properly decides who it serves and why anyone should pick

tl;dr: Each of my clients/start-up founders can tell you the one act that got the business going. A sharp offer.

tl;dr: Your plan probably is not the problem. In most companies I work with, marketing strategy execution breaks down in

Get Growth Strategy Insights
Join founders and business leaders who receive practical marketing frameworks and real-world case studies.
Paaras Panndya logo
Ready to Build Your Growth Engine?
Let’s discuss how a Fractional CMO can bridge the gap between your current performance and your revenue goals.

Why Marketing Decisions Fail When Businesses Misunderstand How Customers Buy